Leasing vs. Buying a Semi Truck: How to Compare the Real Cost
Leasing and buying both get a semi in front of you, but the long-term cost, tax treatment, and flexibility are different in ways that are not obvious from the monthly payment. This guide explains how to put both options on equal footing so you can compare the real cost over the period you plan to operate the truck.
The core difference
When you buy, you own the truck. It depreciates, but equity builds as you pay down the loan and eventually you have an asset worth something. When you lease, you pay for the right to use the truck for a set period. At the end of the lease you either return it, buy it at the residual value, or roll into a new lease. The monthly payment on a lease is almost always lower than on a loan for the same truck — but that comparison is misleading because you are paying for different things.
Types of commercial truck lease
- TRAC lease (Terminal Rental Adjustment Clause)
- The most common commercial truck lease. A residual value is set at the start. At end of term you can buy the truck at that residual, return it and pay the difference if it is worth less than the residual, or return it if it is worth more. TRAC leases are treated as true operating leases for accounting purposes.
- $1 buyout lease (capital lease)
- You make monthly payments and buy the truck for $1 at the end. Economically identical to a loan — you are financing 100% of the value — but structured as a lease. Monthly payments are higher than a TRAC lease because no residual reduces the amount financed. Treated as a capital asset on your balance sheet.
- FMV (Fair Market Value) lease
- You return the truck at the end unless you choose to buy at fair market value. Lower monthly payments than a $1 buyout, but you have no equity at the end unless you exercise the purchase option at whatever the truck is worth then.
How to compare total cost
The only fair comparison is total cost of ownership (TCO) over the same period. For a loan, that is down payment + all monthly payments + any maintenance not covered by warranty. For a lease, it is all monthly payments + the purchase option cost (if you plan to keep the truck) or the return cost (if the truck is worth less than the residual).
Example: $120,000 new truck, 5-year horizon, 8% financing rate.
Buy (loan, 20% down, 60 months at 8%):
Down payment: $24,000 | Monthly: $1,946 | Total payments: $116,760
Total out-of-pocket: $24,000 + $116,760 = $140,760. Residual value after 5 years ≈ $45,000. Net cost: $140,760 − $45,000 = $95,760.
TRAC lease (residual 35% = $42,000, 60 months at 8%):
Monthly payment on $78,000 financed portion at 8%: ≈ $1,579 | Total payments: $94,740
Buy at residual: +$42,000 (if you keep it) | Net cost: $94,740 + $42,000 = $136,740
Return truck: $94,740 + shortfall if value < $42,000 | If truck is worth $45,000: $94,740 − $3,000 credit = $91,740.
The truck lease vs. buy calculator runs both scenarios side by side with your inputs.
Tax treatment
Buying: You depreciate the truck over 5 years (MACRS), or use Section 179 or bonus depreciation to deduct the full cost in year one. Loan interest is also deductible. Leasing: Lease payments are fully deductible as a business expense in the year paid. For a TRAC or FMV lease, there is no depreciation deduction. For a $1 buyout lease, it is treated like a purchase — you depreciate the truck rather than deducting payments.
In high-income years, Section 179 or bonus depreciation on a purchased truck can produce a large deduction upfront. In lower-income years, the steady deduction of lease payments may be more useful. A CPA can model which approach produces the better after-tax outcome for your specific situation.
When leasing tends to win
- You want to operate a newer truck every 3–5 years without the risk of an aging asset.
- Cash flow is tight and the lower monthly payment matters more than long-term equity.
- You are not sure how long you will stay in this lane or business model.
- Maintenance is bundled into a full-service lease and you want predictable operating costs.
When buying tends to win
- You plan to operate the truck for 7–10 years — the longer you hold it after payoff, the more attractive buying becomes.
- You want to build an asset on your balance sheet.
- Your income is high enough to take full advantage of Section 179 depreciation in year one.
- You prefer freedom from mileage limits and wear-and-tear return conditions.
Sources and method
Payment calculations use standard amortisation. Residual value estimates are illustrative. Tax treatment described is for U.S. federal income tax; state rules vary. This page is general information, not financial or tax advice — consult a CPA before making a financing decision.